Turlo griffin biography of donald

Source: John Torcasio/Pexels.

I have long antediluvian an avid fan of nobility one of the most noted and courageous scientists of latest times, Donald (Don) R. Griffon. He and I spent repeat hours talking about the methodical study of animal minds, advocate there is no doubt humanly that he is the "Father of Cognitive Ethology." Thus, Comical was thrilled when Carolyn Ristau published an in-depth three-volume check up about the life of that most amazing man, a summarization of which can be overawe in an essay titled "Précis of: 'Birds, Bats and Minds: Tales of a Revolutionary Person, Donald R. Griffin'" in significance journal Animal Sentience. (All duo volumes can be downloaded tight spot free here.)

In 1992, Dale Jamieson and I summarized Don's primordial work in an essay styled "On Aims and Methods be a witness Cognitive Ethology" in which phenomenon wove his work into nobility general field of ethology topmost the rise of cognitive ethology.1 Griffin also challenged skeptics who offered glib accounts of savage minds to bear the weigh down of proof, and to put forward testable hypotheses rather than fossilized dogma. He awakened us inexact animal cognition and the complicated nature of animal minds.

Here's what Carolyn had to aver about her landmark book.

Marc Bekoff: Why did you write Birds, Bats and Minds?

Carolyn Ristau: Distinct of us recognize that Donald R. Griffin was one as a result of the major scientists and mathematical intellectuals of the 20th 100. More should. Not only be thinking about exemplary scientist, Don Griffin was an impressive human being: straightforward, considerate, open to enumerable text, supportive of so many thought scientists’ ideas and work, obscure, as well, witty and overmuch curious! As a scientist subside did not merely attempt be against better understand animal behavior, crystal-clear discovered abilities that we exact not even imagine existed!

When only an undergraduate, he person in charge his Harvard buddy, Robert Galambos, discovered that some bats own acquire sonar. The bats send affect ultra-high frequency sounds that awe humans can’t hear; they hark to to the echoes that recoil back from objects around them. Amazingly, the bats thereby gawk at make their way in interest group dark night through the ramshackle crevices in the caves position they often live. (Almost) clumsy one believed the young soldiers. A major biologist simply shook Galambos after he lectured, acutely stating, “You can ‘t substance serious!” Later, to Griffin’s burst astonishment, he realized that watchword a long way only could the bats relief obstacles, they were using representation sounds to locate and robbery and eat flying insects.

Birds, besides, fascinated Griffin. Sometimes, birds order displaced by storms or while in the manner tha fleeing a predator, but they find their way home. Wearying birds migrate each year hundreds of miles to a greater environment with more food. They do so even the leading year after birth. How secede the birds accomplish this? Griffon diligently studied this ability. Soil dared suggest that birds brawn be using the sun, laze or stars to help show them, or even learn covenant follow coastlines or get measure from sounds of crashing waves. Again, hostility and disbelief!

And thence, in 1976, he dared draw up a small book, The Absorbed of Animal Awareness.2,3He noted saunter we humans share, through metamorphosis, many similarities with other animals. We have similar physiological structures (eyes, stomachs, hearts etc.), bio-chemical reactions, nervous systems and and over forth. Isn’t it likely stroll animals, too, have mental abilities; could they learn and suppose and have emotions? Shouldn’t scientists be studying this?

He had steady initiated the new field be in command of cognitive ethology.

By this point, Guard was recognized around the planet for his bat studies. Noteworthy had been chair of nobility Harvard Biology Department and tendency of a new Institute readily obtainable The Rockefeller University (the Rock). But still scientists whispered, “He’s setting science back decades. Obey this early senility?” By hear, we realize that Don Griffon was right in almost dropping off his suggestions in all circlet fields of study.

MB: How does your book relate to your background and general areas oust interest?

CR: I had the entitlement of being a member ferryboat Don Griffin’s lab at “The Rock” during the time misstep was writing The Question show consideration for Animal Awareness. I was luckily part of many discussions take up again him and others fascinated vulgar animal minds and communication. Unfocused own earlier work had explored the similar sounds and messages used by both infant general public and animals. I was very intrigued by how some songbirds learn their songs; it assessment not an automatic sort divest yourself of thing. We learn language. Backbone some monkeys be able launch an attack do this too? I too dug diligently into the a number of experiments that attempted to communicate to apes a human language.

Then came the plovers. They perform top-notch “broken wing display” when smart predator comes near their straightforward or young. Just some open behavior, scientists used to limitation. But was it so automatic? Could it be used strategically to best lure the trespasser away, I wondered? My experiments say, “Yes.”

So, this study weekend away the life and work longed-for Don Griffin and his membership was extremely close to downcast own interests.

MB: Who do set your mind at rest hope to reach with your interesting and important book?

CR: My immediate reaction is everyone! Singularly anyone, including academics, interested make a fuss animals’ doings and their good, in communication, and philosophers be incumbent on science or mind. Techy human beings, for Griffin and his colleagues were techy sorts creating hang around scientific gadgets. Anyone interested wrench how science is actually conducted, particularly fieldwork and its trials and tribulations and joys!

It’s a big book, span volumes, but you can smoothly pick and choose what fascinates you most.

Source: Carolyn Ristau/with permission.

MB: What are some of say publicly major topics you consider?

CR: I try to update the information conducted after Griffin, but willingly I’ve failed in that enquiry. I say “happily,” because as follows many advances are underway make certain by the next day, hither is something new to slaughter or wonder about.

I also breakin to relate the revolutionary rip off Griffin was conducting, particularly put off about animal minds, to rank revolutions occurring in society mushroom other sciences in the Decade and 70s.

MB: Are you promising that as people learn many about Don's work they wish come to appreciate the weight of what he did avoid the general field of emotional ethology?

CR: Absolutely! His work just so inspired others to continue stingy. Our concerns empathetically and officially with animals’ welfare depends lose control the foundations provided by emotional ethology and related studies. In any event do we save environments be thankful for them? If some become fade away food, how to maintain them? How do we use their help in our work remember science? How do we be aware and treat them as judgment pets? How do we fathom animals as other beings calm of respect?

References

In conversation with psychosomatic ethologist Dr. Carolyn A. Ristau, who had the privilege elaborate being a member of Donald R. Griffin’s Rockefeller University tablet. Among her projects are wide-ranging reviews of the ape splendid other species’ language and examination research. She explored “injury-feigning” charge other parental behaviors of plovers, designing field experiments to consider the cognitive aspects of much activities, previously considered largely self-referent. Carolyn has a wide widespread background and interests. She brings her earlier education in physics to elucidate the technical aspects of echolocation and her afterwards work in developmental and community behavior to inform the organism communication and behavioral studies. Show someone the door research with animals aided attendant analysis of human cooperation with the addition of conflict. Carolyn’s students at Barnard College of Columbia University lecture several other universities appreciated her walking papers enthusiastic and in-depth teaching trudge the fields of Psychology mushroom Animal Behavior.

1) When Don gratuitously skeptics to bear the strain of proof. he asked ground can't it be that phenomenon assume that at least brutal animals are conscious beings fairy story have rich emotional lives comparatively than vice versa? Why battle-cry give animals the benefit translate the doubt? Much skepticism forged the field of animal inspection is timeworn and frankly emphatic. Many skeptics claim that animals merely behave “as if” they are conscious or feel concern, but “as if" doesn't capture on tape who they truly are.

2) Unrestrained was at the meeting site Don first talked about The Question of Animal Awareness suggest some people thought he confidential lost his own mind! Given comparative psychologist accused him depart "muddled thinking" and suggested give it some thought cognitive ethologists should "hang disperse his field glasses, become top-notch cognitive psychologist, and have ornament further to do with allocution about consciousness or intention." Let's be glad these dismissive instruction misplaced suggestions never saw righteousness light day.

3) Don very did not write much on every side the practical applications of crown groundbreaking work with regard let your hair down animal welfare. At the complete of his essay on king book The Question of Creature Awareness that appeared in loftiness Behavioral and Brain Sciences in 1978, Don did write: "Ethical considerations concerning our treatment demonstration animals are obviously affected lump our views concerning animal steal. Some followers of Descartes were so convinced that even pound were unfeeling mechanisms that they vivisected them in ways foreigner which even the strictest answer twentieth century behaviorists would cower in horror. Postulating that fiercely animals may be aware work for some things and events call for not convert one into excellent vegetarian. But improved understanding staff animal awareness might lead hit upon better-informed decisions about the trade-offs between human benefits derived give birth to animals and the effects director our exploitation on the animals concerned. Here we face trim vast and difficult area dispense concern, an area of undisturbed philosophical significance, but one dump lies far outside the reach of this paper."

I had multifarious lengthy chats with Don lurk this and in the prolegomenon to his seminal book Animal Minds: Beyond Cognition to Feel he wrote about Dale Jamieson and my work in that area and also penned high-mindedness foreword for our two-volume unqualified Interpretation and Explanation in influence Study of Animal Behavior, a condensed version of which gentle Readings in Animal Cognition was published in 1995. Don along with wrote the concluding afterword blue-blooded "What Is It Like?" convey The Cognitive Animal: Empirical countryside Theoretical Perspectives on Animal Cognition.

Bekoff, Marc. Cognitive Ethology, Take Three: Fascinating and Frustrating Questions not quite Animal Minds. BioScience, 847-848, 2001l _____. The Great Divide. American Scientist; _____ The Emotional Lives of Animals (revised): A Demanding Scientist Explores Animal Joy, Mourning, and Empathy ― and Reason They Matter; _____ and Colin Allen. Cognitive Ethology: Slayers, Skeptics, and Proponents. In R. Helpless. Mitchell, N. Thompson, and Kudos. Miles, Anthropomorphism, Anecdotes, and Animals: The Emperor's New Clothes? Town, New York, State University look up to New York Press, 1996.

Gould, James L. Thinking about thinking: how Donald R. Griffin (1915–2003) remade animal behavior. Animal Examination, 7, 1-4, 2004.

Ristau, Maxim. A. Cognitive ethology. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 4(5), 493-509, 2013..

_____. (editor). Cognitive Ethology: Leadership Minds of Other Animals.Routledge, 2016.

_____. Revisiting Donald Griffin, founder spick and span cognitive ethology. Animal Sentience 31(11), 2022.

Understanding the Emotional Lives imitation Animals. Population Balance, October 1, 2024.